AN NRT EXCLUSIVE EDITORIAL
Top 10 Christmas Playlist
Senior Editor Marcus Hathcock shares his Top 10 songs to be played this Christmas season.
 


I love Christmastime for many reasons, but one of them has to be the songs. It's awesome to have special songs just for this season -- songs that point us to the tremendous anticipation and arrival of the King who was come for us. 
 
While my dear colleague Kevin Davis shared his favorite renditions of traditional Christmas songs last week, this week I'm sharing my Top 10 Christmas songs to put in your playlist this Christmas 2012. These are full of celebration songs, some somber moments, and even some stuff you've never heard before. 
 
(Check out the playlist on MOG here.)
 
"Hark the Herald Angels Sing" by Seabird
I could fill this entire list with songs from the fantastic 2010 EP, Over the Hills and Everywhere, but for this list, I've picked two. My favorite from this album is the lullaby-vibed "Hark the Herald Angels Sing." The thing about this album is that while the lyrics are that of the classic songs, the melodies, tempos and song construction are completely original. While the original "Hark" is a triumphant, big-sounding anthem, Seabird's version is more subdued at first, giving way to a foot-stomping, front porch banjo jam. It's a celebration, for sure, and the fresh coat of paint gives new life and attention to the lyrics we all know.
 
"O Holy Night" by Pentatonix
Now, a cappella wizards Pentatonix isn't a Christian band (although the vocal percussionist, Kevin "K.O." Olusa has been a part of the Gungor collective), but their thick, heartfelt, jazz-inspired, melodically complex version of my all-time favorite Christmas song is remarkable. The quintet's blend is fantastic, and the various musical choices they make in the various chordal structures is almost too much to take in. You can't hardly believe that just five people are producing so much music! This is a must-listen for the holidays, found on the PTXmas EP.


"Christmas Song" by Flyleaf
Back in 2007, the band formerly fronted by Lacey Mosely-Sturm released a little-known single simply titled "Christmas Song." Flyleaf's repetitive but powerful acoustic ballad profoundly describes the true reason for the season. The most gut-wrenching lyric: "The goodness bound by Satan it has been torn / 
With this baby's precious brow ready for thorns."
 
"O Come O Come Emmanuel" by Starfield
The newly independent Starfield, fresh off their release The Kingdom, has quickly reemerged with their Christmas EP, Songs For Christmas Vol. 1. (So does that mean more Christmas music is forthcoming? Hmm…)
 
The soothing vocals of Tim Neufeld paint a hypnotic soundscape, flanked by haunting high harmonies that passionately capture the longing for Messiah and the relief of His arrival. Fans of The Kingdom will feel right at home with this musically excellent and dramatic track.
 
"The First Noel" by tobyMac (feat. Owl City)
This song from Christmas in Diverse City is just a blast. It's got the high energy and good beat you'd expect from a tobyMac song. It's well produced. It's catchy. It's singable. And, to add to all that, it's got Owl City (Adam Young) singing along. It's a great pairing of these two heavyweights, and it makes the typically mundane chorus of the song -- "Noel, noel, noel, noel, born is the King of Israel" -- fairly exciting and head bobbing. Have a good time… this is supposed to be a birthday celebration!
 
 
"That Was the Worst Christmas Ever!" by Sufjan Stevens
If you're unfamiliar with Sufjan Stevens, I'm pleased to introduce you. Sufjan and your smooth vocals, witty and poetic lyrics and mastery of unconventional instruments, meet the readers. Readers, meet "That Was the Worst Christmas Ever!" from the Songs For Christmas album.
 
Despite the seemingly funny title of this song, it's actually a quite sad tale that begins happily in the snow, and ends with the haunting line: "Silent night, nothing feels right." 
 
It's the story of a father flipping out on a family during Christmas, "throwing the gifts in the wood stove," and a sibling running away. It's a raw, honest retelling, and one that forces us to focus on the Love that should define the season. 

"He Has Come For Us (God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen) by Meredith Andrews
It seems a popular thing to do these days to take an old hymn or Christmas song and freshen it up by slapping a brand-new chorus onto it. The songs on A Very Special Christmas do a good job of augmenting the good that's already inherent in the classics.
 
Rather than shoehorn a chorus onto "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen," the song "He Has Come For Us," in my opinion, enhances the original, providing a unifying, summarizing declaration that provides the context for all the Old English stanzas: "He has come for us, this Jesus / He's the hope for all mankind / He has come for us, the Messiah / Born to give us life."

Meredith Andrews provides powerhouse vocals that resound as someone calling into the wilderness, to a world that desperately needs to hear this news. 
 
 
"Born is the King (It's Christmas)" by Hillsong LIVE
If Christmas happened in the summertime, what would a song for the season sound like? Ask the Aussies; Christmas always happens in the heat of summer down under. Mix the youthful joy and happiness of a summer anthem with the genuine elation of the coming of the Messiah, and you have this brand-new tune from Hillsong
 
Many Christmas songs are serious (and understandably so), and others just have triumphant words that are hard to difficult to translate outside a hymn's structure, so this kind of Easter-energied song is rare to find during Christmas. It's seriously among the happiest Christmas songs I've ever heard, and on We Have A Savior, there's more where that came from. Play it over and over. And dance.
 
"What Child Is This" by Seabird
There are no "Greensleeves" melodies here. Strumming electric guitars, synths and pianos accompany a Brit-pop feel that turns the traditional hymn into a toe-tapper.
 
As I said before (regarding "Hark…") Seabird's album really takes advantage of the profound lyrics of the traditional hymns. With this sort of musical treatment, we trade the mysterious sounding original melody for a more declarative, celebratory rock opera aria of sorts. I could imagine any number of the Seabird Christmas songs serving as the soundtrack for a modern Christmas program.

"O Holy Night" by Group 1 Crew
Pop/rock hip-hoppers Group 1 Crew took a page out of the Seabird playbook and took my all-time favorite Christmas song, "O Holy Night," and changed up the melodies while keeping much of the original lyrics the same.
 
I'm not a purist by any stretch of the imagination. I like that I can listen to both a fabulous traditional, jazz-influenced a cappella version of the song by Pentatonix and a completely danceable version by G1C (complete with Manwell rap) and love them both. Check this song out on the recently released two-song Christmas EP. Just don't expect the same feel as the original. 
 

NRT Senior Editor Marcus Hathcock has been a newspaper reporter, an editor and now Community Life Director for East Hill Church in Gresham, Ore. He's also been involved in opera, acappella, a CCM group and now is a songwriter and one of the worship leaders at East Hill. Follow his journey at www.mheternal.com.

Christian Music, Devotionals, Interviews, Editorials
Brandon Heath
NEW! BEHIND THE SONG
#1296 - Mary-Clair

A candid conversation about faith, vulnerability, and finding God
 

ADVERTISEMENT
Miracle
NEW! MOVIE REVIEW
Miracle

NRT reviews the new movie after attending the premiere
 
Christmas Worship
NEW! SERIES REVIEW
A Night At Wingfeather

We attended the show's premiere of the Angel Studios animated show
Worship 2026
NEW! NRT LISTS
Worship Into 2026

Standout new worship releases that invite the Church to sing and reflect
 
The CHH Drop
NEW! THE CHH DROP
#261 - Gavin the Hotrod

What's new this week in Christian rap and hip-hop

Christian Music, Facebook Christian Music, Twitter Christian Music, YouTube Christian Music, Instagram

ADVERTISEMENTS

Christian Music

©2026 NewReleaseToday
A Division Of NRT Media Inc.

 

Secure
CHRISTIAN MUSIC
Discover New Artists
New This Week
Coming Soon
Playlists
Free Music
Album Reviews

NEWS
New Music
Movies / Media
Events
Tours
General

PODCASTS
NRT Now Podcast
NRT Podcast Network

VIDEOS
Music Videos
Exclusives

EXCLUSIVES
Articles
Devotionals
Interviews
Concert Reviews
We Love Awards

MORE INFO
RSS
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Advertising
Staff
New Music Email
Contact

RESOURCES
Music Studies
Artist Training

CONNECT
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
YouTube