In the midst of Libby's matchmaking attempts to bring together her father and Annika, a gifted violinist boards the Christina. Then Pa asks Libby, Caleb, Jordan, and Peter, "What's most important to you? What do you really want?" As they seek the answer for their own lives, they also face mysteries and hardships: Who stole the fiddler's treasured violin? What has become of Annika? Can the Christina possibly escape an ice storm? And what is the fiddler's secret?